I asked for something new since I want to fill up my catalogue, and I got a flooring. Don't remember which. From what I've seen, something expensive rarely seems to actually give you something worth very much, lol.
Your rhinestone eyes are like
factories far away
^I'm pretty sure he just gives you regular furniture. in the gamecube game his three reward options were weeding the town, painting your roof or giving you something you don't have in your catalogue. in CF it was the same, except instead of painting your roof, he would squash roaches in your house. I think your best bet is to choose something new every time, because then at the very least it'll help you fill out your catalogue
Visit my NL dream towns!
Angie from Maplerow, Ranae from Wayfield and Olive from Yorkwood