44,140 bells
 
 
» General AC Discussion Board
Topic: Underrated/Overrated Villagers

Page of 8
Brownjoe
 
Name
Brian
ACNL Town
Last Active
4/11/2020 8:40pm
Every single town I go to or see on the internet seems to have the same 20 or so villagers in it. Julian, Marshal, Merengue, Ankha, Fauna, etc. are all examples of villagers that are in literally so many towns that they've lost meaning to me. Am I really the only person out there that doesn't find these villagers to be particularly fascinating? Don't get me wrong, I like a lot of them, but if I had to compile a list of "dreamies" I don't think they'd necessarily be my first choices.

What underrated villagers do you like? Frank is one of my personal favorites.
What overrated villagers do you dislike? I've never liked Lucky ever since I was a kid playing AC:WW.

-Amrasje (8/29/2015 6:31:20 AM)
Moving to General Animal Crossing Discussion.
Signature--------------

sure
Bells: 1,384,785 Catalog: 1519 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (24) Patterns: 8  
K3ology
 
Name
K3ology
ACGC Town
Last Active
9/20 10:17pm
I'm basing the place they're in on what the majority of the internet thinks about them. So if they all hate them they're underrated if they all like them they're overrated


Underrated ones I like: Sydney, Chow

Sort of in the middles I like: Any of my dreamies that aren't Sydney or Chow

Overrated ones I dislike: Julian, Lucky, Zucker (his name is too close to the other word, I'm fine with Huck though)

I mean I like Marshal, Phoebe, Fauna, Ankha, etc. but they aren't my first choices for dreamies.
Signature--------------
I want to get a skateboard where the design is one of those mom decorations
Like "live laugh love" or "it's fall y'all" or something.
Bells: 489,700 Catalog: 171 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (3) Patterns: 0  
Jaycee_023
 
Name
Jack
ACNL Town
Last Active
3/28/2020 2:17am
I never hear Jeremiah, Ricky, or Midge talked about, and they're some of my favorites! I too never cared much for Julian or Marshal. I got Julian during my 16 villager cycle for Lopez (the only smug for me) and I just gave him away.
Signature--------------
I live with the hope of reobtaining Lopez </3
The 16 villager cycle sucks. Don't put yourself in that position.
Bells: 89,100 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (19) Patterns: 0  
K3ology
 
Name
K3ology
ACGC Town
Last Active
9/20 10:17pm
The only smugs I like are O'Hare and Tex.
Signature--------------
I want to get a skateboard where the design is one of those mom decorations
Like "live laugh love" or "it's fall y'all" or something.
Bells: 489,700 Catalog: 171 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (3) Patterns: 0  
Florb
 
Name
Flora
ACNL Town
Last Active
9/18 12:11pm
I can't get over why everyone seems to be so obsessed over Julian, he really isn't all that imho. I always think part of the game is the fact you get a mix of unpredictable animals so it seems weird to me to be choosing them for yourself.

Underrated villagers I love, Rowan, Bill and Tipper. They're all really sweet although my fondness may be partially down to them being in my town in Wild World
Signature--------------
I was told when I get older all my fears would shrink
But now I'm insecure, and I care what people think. [ACC+5 - UK]
Bells: 192,500 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (119) Patterns: 42  
wheatly4ever
 
Last Active
10/22/2017 7:25am
Most of my dreamies ( anhka,lucky,zucker etc.) Are top or second tier  but I like them because of personal reasons not because I want a so called 'perfect' town
I want lucky because he's awesome
I want anhka because she is a perfect snooty to go with lucky
I want Pietro because he's freaking clown sheep
I want Bob because he's fabulous
I want chadder because he's cheesy
I want lolly because I love her and she is my last original villager
I want lobo because he's amazing
I want sydney because Sydney is best koala
I want coco because she's underated
Signature--------------
obtained dreamies: peitro, Rudy, coco, lucky and ankha
LF: Zucker, Rosie, Lolly, Lobo and Bob
Bells: 284,830 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (63) Patterns: 0  
K3ology
 
Name
K3ology
ACGC Town
Last Active
9/20 10:17pm
I also have an extreme liking bordering to obsession w/ O'Hare

I don't know how popular he is but it's sorta creepy
Signature--------------
I want to get a skateboard where the design is one of those mom decorations
Like "live laugh love" or "it's fall y'all" or something.
Bells: 489,700 Catalog: 171 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (3) Patterns: 0  
PhailBoat
 
Name
Boop
ACNL Town
Last Active
6/8/2021 10:17am
Yeah, tbh I'm obsessed with Julian and can't make a town w/o him, but i definitely don't understand the appeal of Marshal.
Bells: 178,200 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (74) Patterns: 0  
Shawnaisus
 
Name
Shawna
ACNL Town
Last Active
9/20 3:01am
Personally, I think Peaches is the most underrated villager.  She is a normal villager, making her sweet, plus she is soooooo cute.

And I think Rolf is very overrated.  Most people think he is the nicest cranky, but he's always been the rudest to me.
Signature--------------
"On a scale from 1 to 10, these children are 15."
- Nanny Stella
Bells: 470,400 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (17) Patterns: 1  
K3ology
 
Name
K3ology
ACGC Town
Last Active
9/20 10:17pm
People don't like normal villagers because they aren't "interesting" like jocks or cranky villagers.

IT'S IN THEIR NAME! "NORMAL" VILLAGER! WHAT DID YOU EXPECT?
Signature--------------
I want to get a skateboard where the design is one of those mom decorations
Like "live laugh love" or "it's fall y'all" or something.
Bells: 489,700 Catalog: 171 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (3) Patterns: 0  
Kimpendous
 
Name
Kim
ACNL Town
Last Active
1/19/2018 9:07pm
Walt the cranky kangaroo moved in early in my Crossing of Animals, and I ended up really liking him! Most of my town is made up of dreamies (with two original villagers), and Walt's the only one who moved in randomly that I won't let leave XD
Signature--------------
Citizens of Pugtopia: Chief, Diana, Fang, Filbert,
Lopez, Marshal, Pashmina, and Walt! <3
Bells: 94,600 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (104) Patterns: 1  
Jimmy365
 
Name
Jimmy
ACGC Town
Last Active
2/14/2017 9:47am
Bob is so overrated.... Bunnie is so underrated
Signature--------------
I love Peanut. She is so pretty.. :) lol
Bells: 98,500 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (112) Patterns: 2  
K3ology
 
Name
K3ology
ACGC Town
Last Active
9/20 10:17pm
I also don't see why everyone is so obsessed w/ Pashmina.

Everyone says they cried when she moved, the day she moved out of my town I think I heard angels singing
Signature--------------
I want to get a skateboard where the design is one of those mom decorations
Like "live laugh love" or "it's fall y'all" or something.
Bells: 489,700 Catalog: 171 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (3) Patterns: 0  
Munchy101
 
Name
Wrighty
ACNL Town
Last Active
7/22/2021 9:48pm
i love chester!!
Bells: 343,800 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (324) Patterns: 21  
K3ology
 
Name
K3ology
ACGC Town
Last Active
9/20 10:17pm
Nobody likes Canberra for some reason.

And here I am, having three pictures from her and talking to her at least 50 times a day.

And whoever doesn't like her... I don't like them *kicks can further down the alley*
Signature--------------
I want to get a skateboard where the design is one of those mom decorations
Like "live laugh love" or "it's fall y'all" or something.
Bells: 489,700 Catalog: 171 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (3) Patterns: 0  
wheatly4ever
 
Last Active
10/22/2017 7:25am
The only thing I don't like about Canberra are her eyebrows I have a thing against eyebrows like that
Signature--------------
obtained dreamies: peitro, Rudy, coco, lucky and ankha
LF: Zucker, Rosie, Lolly, Lobo and Bob
Bells: 284,830 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (63) Patterns: 0  
K3ology
 
Name
K3ology
ACGC Town
Last Active
9/20 10:17pm
^ I thought her brows were weird the first time I ever saw her.

She's not the cutest but she grows on you.
Signature--------------
I want to get a skateboard where the design is one of those mom decorations
Like "live laugh love" or "it's fall y'all" or something.
Bells: 489,700 Catalog: 171 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (3) Patterns: 0  
margierules2000
 
Last Active
4/1/2020 7:15pm
I think Filbert is underrated, because I've only seen him in like one village so far. He's one of my favorite villagers and I'd be happy if he moved into my town.
Signature--------------
Let's all come together in peace
Bells: 0 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (36) Patterns: 0  
SpaceOtter
 
Last Active
12/5/2015 11:02am
Biskit has been my favourite since the GameCube era. I also like Walt Jr. and Chow a lot
Signature--------------
Seasickcomic.com - updates Wednesdays! (usually :p)
Bells: 39,200 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (18) Patterns: 0  
K3ology
 
Name
K3ology
ACGC Town
Last Active
9/20 10:17pm
Next to none of my dreamies are actually "popular" AHEM AHEM but here's why I want them.

Tex: I originally was gonna let him go to get Eugene, but seeing how cute he is w/ Lucy... I just can't.
Annalise: I confused Annalise w/ Annalisa so I thought I was going to get the anteater chick but I got her, the horse, she just grew on me so I decided to keep her.
Lucy: I think at one point in time I was gonna let her go for IDK who, but she grew on me and I can't let her go now. Plus I think she's the last original in my town.
Canberra: Same w/ Lucy although that changed sooner after she moved in.
O'Hare: I originally wanted Cherry, but seeing how absolutely obsessed I am w/ O'Hare I felt my town wouldn't be complete without him in it.
Doc: I wanted Chester originally, but then I realized: Boone was the only villager from my old CF town I liked. So I just ditched Chester and went with Doc.
Sydney: She's in my current City Folk town and I just REALLY LIKE HER A LOT so I want her in New Leaf.
Boone: I have, and originally wanted Iggly but Iggly is a terrible villager so I went with the other jock from my old CF town.
Carmen: One of my middle-class dreamies but I have her in CF so I got her in NL, with the added effect of me FREAKING OUT when I saw her in the campsite.
Chow: I originally wanted Curt but I decided to break the ice w/ Chow one day then he just grew on me.
Signature--------------
I want to get a skateboard where the design is one of those mom decorations
Like "live laugh love" or "it's fall y'all" or something.
Bells: 489,700 Catalog: 171 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (3) Patterns: 0  
stephxduloc
 
Name
Steph
ACNH Town
Dream Code
0218-4261-7295
Last Active
9/20 3:18pm
I dont like Lucky, Ankha, Julian, or Merengue. I see why people do, but they arent for me. I do like Marshall, but i think that largely has to do with the fact that his expression reminds me of my old cat, who always looked angry all the time. I personally love my little koala Melba. She was my best friend in Wild World and I would do anything to get her in New Leaf. Octavian is also VERY underrated. Especially considering the popularity of Marina and Zucker. I like him too, he was in my Wild World town and along with Melba, I grew attached to him.
Signature--------------
stephxgeode on Nookazon!
Feel free to PM me about my listings!
Bells: 525,620 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (36) Patterns: 0  
K3ology
 
Name
K3ology
ACGC Town
Last Active
9/20 10:17pm
Yes I loooooove Melba. I mean I like Sydney, but Melba. Melba is at least twice as cute and I also have her in WW. (I hate to say this but if Melba shows up in the campsite before Sydney she's coming into town, sorry Sydney)

Plus I agree 100% about Octavian. He's honestly the coolest octopus villager but everyone is so obsessed w/ Marina and ZUCKER that he's left out in the dark, poor guy.

I mean I like Ankha, she's cool but she's NOWHERE CLOSE to my favorite islander. I mean O'Hare is like the best islander ever, and I don't know how popular he is, and Annalise runs close up behind.

Like I said I don't know the popularity of O'Hare but he is AWESOME HE'S SO COOL DAJSDFANDFA.
Signature--------------
I want to get a skateboard where the design is one of those mom decorations
Like "live laugh love" or "it's fall y'all" or something.
Bells: 489,700 Catalog: 171 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (3) Patterns: 0  
stephxduloc
 
Name
Steph
ACNH Town
Dream Code
0218-4261-7295
Last Active
9/20 3:18pm
I had O'Hare in my campsite and his little hat was so cute I had to invite him to my town. He was fun to have as a resident. I honestly dont understand why Octavian isnt more popular. I mean, hes one of three octopi in the game. Is it because people dont like the cranky personality?
Signature--------------
stephxgeode on Nookazon!
Feel free to PM me about my listings!
Bells: 525,620 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (36) Patterns: 0  
K3ology
 
Name
K3ology
ACGC Town
Last Active
9/20 10:17pm
If O'Hare appeared in my campsite I would pinch myself to let myself know if I was dreaming or not.

But I'm really tied up on whether I should let Melba or Sydney in my town. When I first made my dream villager list I was considering dropping Sydney for Melba; and if I asked every Animal Crossing Community member I know I think I know exactly who would say Sydney or Melba. Now that I saw you say Melba I remembered my old consideration and am now deciding. I'm going to watch a video chat my friend will send when he watches fireworks for the 4th-- maybe that will help me decide. But still this will (hopefully) be my last dream list revision-- just need to decide on a normal koala.
Signature--------------
I want to get a skateboard where the design is one of those mom decorations
Like "live laugh love" or "it's fall y'all" or something.
Bells: 489,700 Catalog: 171 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (3) Patterns: 0  
Denisekay
 
Name
Kayla
ACNL Town
Last Active
11/7/2021 7:19pm
I'm not really fond of many of the more popular villagers either such as Meringue, Ankha, Julian, Marina, Octavian etc. I had Marshal in my town through streetpass for quite a while and he's a cute little guy but I eventually let him go anyway. A bunch of my favorite aren't that high ranked. Hamlet, Daisy, Eugene, Goldie and even my all time favorite Kiki are all ranked relatively low.
Signature--------------
"If you can't convince them, confuse them."
Bells: 187,500 Catalog: 0 Feedback: 0 WiFi:  (117) Patterns: 0  
General AC Discussion Board » Topic: Underrated/Overrated Villagers

Page of 8

Legend:   Site Owner    Administrator    Moderator    Researcher    Developer    Scout    New Member   Honorary Citizen   Birthday