This is my 2nd day throwing my axe in the fountain. I'm asked if I threw in a regular axe. I answer honestly that it is. Then she throws me back the same axe. What gives? I thought honestly was rewarded. Should I tell a lie or just keep throwing it in? I've figured out that I can only do it once a day. <disappointed in greytown>
Serena is a pain. Just keep doing it. Youll eventually get something. Im still working on my gold axe. Going on a week and a half. Although she did give me a silver axe a couple days ago. Dont know how many normal axes I have lost to her though!
Signature--------------
We're the dream warriors!
"Seat thyselves sultanically amongst the moons of Saturn."
3rd time is not a charm....She fooled me into thinking I was going to get a golden axe, then said she ran out. She went on to say that she would give me a silver and I got the same story. I did get my regular axe back.
Its like you going to chop something down in front of the fountain the axe flys over into the fountain and the godess comes out Then she will ask you some question or have something to say to you
Signature--------------
Only look forward never back ..
Treasure true friendship they are hard to find..
Yes, you can throw the regular axe in the fountain, once a day until you get your silver or gold axe. These don't break when you are chopping down trees. The gold axe will cut the tree down faster....or so I'm told. I'm still paying for new axes.
I've been trying for nearly a month in-game, but Serena is stubborn as ever. One time I could have sworn she was going to hand over the golden axe, but noooo, she changed her mind at the last second.
We have four characters, and after one week no one has received a gold or silver axe. About 4 or 5 have been lost to Serena. I read somewhere that the answer she desires will change daily. More than once Serena has told a character that she will give them a gold axe only to be out of them. Then she is also conveniently out of silver axes as well. My husband thinks this is completely for the birds and will no longer contribute to her black market supply.
After two months of axe tossing, Serena still has a head on her shoulders. One of these times that axe is gonna work!
I have received two silver axes so far. But no gold one. I have found that she seems to prefer the honest answers over lies. You have a better chance of at least getting your regular axe back when you answer honestly. As far as I can tell, it's pretty much completely random.
She is the only character in the game that brings out my potty mouth.
Signature--------------
It's never too late to have a happy childhood.
CF players, whoa that's trippy--imagine what would happen in real life if we all went around throwing axes into fountains day after day! I should think an arrest would be underway, at least in most parts of the world.
WW is so much saner--or is it??? I can't tell anymore after midnight...
The dialogue pattern sounds exactly like the one my friend described when he got his silver axe.
- Toss in axe - She asks what type of axe you threw in - Answer 'regular axe' - She offers golden axe but doesn't have any - Asks if you want the silver axe instead - Answer 'yes, please' - She says "oh good!", explains the axe, and then you have the silver axe.
I'm so excited, it's taken ages for her to cooperate!
I just have to add that I had no idea what you all were talking about at first. I kept going to the city with a shovel and couldn't figure out why my fountain guardian wouldn't come to life to talk with me.
Signature--------------
Give a man a fish and he will eat for a day.
Teach him how to fish and he will sit in a boat and drink beer all day.
Posted:
1/5/2009 8:03pm
Casa
Im still working on my gold axe. Going on a week and a half. Although she did give me a silver axe a couple days ago. Dont know how many normal axes I have lost to her though! 
Jen
5
